About 30 minutes into the Season 2 premiere of Apple TV’s most underrated slow-burn mystery, The Last Thing He Told Me, Jennifer Garner’s watchful and pragmatic Hannah Hall gets attacked in her own home. At first, the chilling break-in finds her genuinely shaken, but in the moments that follow, something shifts as she fights back. Stepping far from the simmering tone of the streamer’s debut in 2023, the sequence isn’t flashy or stylized in a way more suited to Garner’s iconic Sydney Bristow in Alias. Instead, it gives the vibe of someone who has spent five years waiting for this very moment.
This unsettling, edge-of-your-seat moment serves as the meat of The Last Thing He Told Me Season 2. While the first season was about Hannah being thrown into chaos, the show’s return is more about what happens when you’ve been living with that underlying mess for so long that it becomes part of you. In what feels like a totally (and tonally) different show, it’s almost as if Reese Witherspoon’s Hello Sunshine-produced series, based on the books by New York Times bestselling author Laura Dave, represents more than a mere tweak or reset. The mystery framework is still intact across Season 2’s eight episodes, but it’s been built into something sharper and more propulsive.
What Is ‘The Last Thing He Told Me’ Season 2 About?
One of the smartest things the Apple TV show has done is stop pretending that the mystery is the point of everything. While Season 1 was about Owen’s (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) disappearance and his murky past, Season 2 doesn’t waste time on setup. Instead, we see Owen has been living off the grid for five years and working undercover for U.S. Marshal Grady (Augusto Aguilera), snapping photos from rooftops and trying to dismantle the powerful and wealthy Campano family. He also sneaks a visit to see Hannah while in disguise, but none of it is ever romanticized. If anything, Owen is positioned as a wrecking ball to the stability that Hannah and his daughter, Bailey (Angourie Rice), have built in their new home in Los Angeles.
Season 2 is really a story about a family reuniting under pressure, and Owen’s goal is simple on paper — finish the job, get out clean, and return home — but the show never pretends that the fix is easy. His years-long absence compounds all the damage of being kept in the dark following his abrupt exit in Season 1. Hannah and Bailey have been doing well on their own. Bailey is older, more independent, in college, and has a boyfriend, but while Hannah maintains a normal life, she’s also quietly built systems that speak to her instinct for danger. When she’s attacked early in the first episode, “Cape Cod,” and instinctively fights back, it’s equal parts scary and inevitable. This is a woman who has been creating contingency plans, securing emergency funds, and training for self-defense in the park with her instructor for nearly half a decade.
As things begin to get messy and some mysterious men are in pursuit of the pair (along with two others trailing Hannah and Bailey), the tension is never just about outside threats closing in, but rather the internal ones that rely on someone else always controlling the narrative. With Bailey needing answers about her mother, she gets mixed up with a member of the Campano family, Quinn (Judy Greer), despite everyone warning her against it. Naturally, Hannah is stuck in the middle, trying to protect her daughter while also figuring out what kind of life they can have with Owen, which is why Season 2 isn’t less of a whodunit and more of a pressure-cooker story about whether this trio can stay together once the truth finally stops being optional.
‘The Last Thing He Told Me’s Cast Gets a Bigger Playground for Season 2
While Garner has always been the beating heart of the Apple TV series, Season 2 gives her a lot more momentum than Season 1. This isn’t to say she plays Hannah like an action star; she also balances the character’s fatigue with a capability that feels more earned than anything. Even when Hannah is calm or thinking things through, Garner gives her a constant sense of hyper-awareness, like she’s mentally measuring exits and risks. Quieter beats, especially in scenes with Rice, are where she barely has to speak to communicate her fears, frustrations, or that kind of parental exhaustion that comes from always being the responsible one. As much as Season 2 belongs to Garner, it’s also a huge upgrade for Coster-Waldau, whose character was mostly a ghost the first time around and finally gets to be a real person. While some of his choices might rile up Hannah and Bailey, there’s a quiet desperation to Coster-Waldau’s performance as the prodigal patriarch, who needs to be 10 steps ahead, even in scenes that feel more personal within the family.
While Rice isn’t as front and center as last season, she does a lot of emotional heavy lifting. Bailey spends time caught between a need to go forward, but is also unable to stop pulling at the past, and Rice plays this tension flawlessly. She’s especially good at letting Bailey’s yearning show in the space between a beat that lingers too long or a look that turns from curiosity to hurt in a split second, particularly in moments with Greer and an unrecognizable Rita Wilson, who plays Hannah’s estranged and emotionally distant mother, Carole. Wilson refuses to soften her character for likability, which is exactly why she works in the small dose we get.
The 30 Best Apple TV+ Original Series, Ranked
The best of the bunch.
Greer is one of The Last Thing He Told Me‘s most electric additions this season. With an immediate edge to every scene she’s in, her character has a welcoming warmth to her interactions with Bailey, and Greer plays friendly threat with the right amount of control and depth. Her easy chemistry with Garner is so much fun to watch, and while diehard 13 Going on 30 fans will love seeing them interact, that kind of real-life friendship can run the risk of their scenes becoming one-note. That is never the case here. Instead, each moment between them is defined by a push-and-pull filled with distrust and recognition between two women who understand each other more than they want to admit. Supporting Greer are incredible performances from Luke Kirby as her erratic and power-hungry little brother, Teddy Campano, and her cold, watchful father, John Noble, as Frank Campano. The pair’s presence hangs over the series, never once feeling like cartoon crime bosses and making things feel a lot bigger and more dangerous than ever.
‘The Last Thing He Told Me’ Elevates Its Writing in Season 2
One of the biggest improvements in The Last Thing He Told Me this time around is how the writing stops tiptoeing into some of Season 1’s more atmospheric, moody beats. Of course, the show had an effective hook, but it often felt like it was stretching itself to preserve its overall puzzle without moving the story forward. While Season 1 could have gotten away with being a movie for Apple TV, Season 2 earns its status as a series. This time, the plots and characters move with more direction and purpose. The pacing is also a lot tighter, with higher stakes that feel earned instead of carefully plotted. Even when the season leans into more action or larger set pieces like a fight scene or even a car chase, the writing never loses sight of the story’s emotional center.
Another thing that viewers might appreciate is how the season builds suspense not through a mystery, but through the characters’ choices. The danger is never just about who’s following Hannah or Bailey, but in how they’re forced to rely on people they can’t really trust. The show pulls at threads that also alter the story’s tone, creating a sharp paranoia that gives the season a faint edge of noir through morally murky instances, shadowy figures, and decisions that always come with a cost.
Although The Last Thing He Told Me Season 2 is informed by Dave’s novels, it’s clear the show has grown beyond the limits of the source material, including taking some liberties in adapting the book for the small screen. As this season deepens its conflicts and expands its world, however, there are some moments where it relies too heavily on explaining itself. Some of it is necessary clarity, but this narrative housekeeping also interrupts the season’s momentum. Overall, The Last Thing He Told Me Season 2 is a lot more confident in taking risks, emphasizing the rarity of a follow-up that doesn’t just continue the story but energetically improves the entire show to date.
The Last Thing He Told Me Season 2 premieres February 20 on Apple TV.
- Release Date
-
April 13, 2023
- Network
-
Apple TV
- Showrunner
-
Laura Dave, Josh Singer
-
Jennifer Garner
Hannah Hall
-
Angourie Rice
Bailey Michaels
Pros & Cons
- Season 2 is sharper and more propulsive, turning its slow-burn DNA into real edge-of-your-seat tension.
- Garner is the beating heart of Season 2, playing fatigue and earned capability with a hyper-aware precision that never slips.
- Greer is electric, playing that “friendly threat” with control, depth, and chemistry that crackles opposite Garner.
- A few set pieces flirt with familiar thriller rhythms, even if the show keeps its emotional center intact.
- A later episode over-explains what’s happening, breaking the momentum when it should be sprinting.
