What is Amy Fisher’s net worth?
Amy Fisher is an American writer and actress who has a net worth of $200 thousand.
Amy Fisher’s name became synonymous with one of the most sensational crime stories of the early 1990s. As a teenager, Fisher was thrust into the national spotlight after shooting Mary Jo Buttafuoco, the wife of her much older lover, auto body shop owner Joey Buttafuoco. The case exploded into a nonstop media spectacle that blended crime reporting with tabloid obsession, daytime talk shows, and made-for-TV dramatizations. Fisher’s youth, the salacious details of the affair, and the suburban Long Island setting helped turn a criminal case into a cultural phenomenon that dominated headlines for years.
Although the shooting left Mary Jo Buttafuoco permanently injured, she survived and later rebuilt her life in public view, while Fisher became a polarizing figure. To some, she was a manipulative criminal who committed attempted murder. To others, she was a troubled minor who had been groomed and exploited by an adult man. The legal outcome reflected that ambiguity, with Fisher ultimately pleading guilty to lesser charges rather than standing trial for attempted murder. After serving prison time, she reemerged repeatedly in the public eye, navigating a complicated path through memoirs, interviews, reality television, and later a controversial pivot into adult entertainment. Decades after the shooting, Fisher remains a touchstone for conversations about media exploitation, victimhood, and how scandal can permanently define a public identity.
Early Life
Amy Elizabeth Fisher was born on August 21, 1974, in Merrick, New York, and grew up on Long Island. By her mid-teens, she was working at an auto body shop owned by Joey Buttafuoco, who was more than a decade older and married with children. Their relationship, which began when Fisher was still a minor, later became central to public debate over consent, power imbalance, and responsibility. At the time, Fisher was described as a struggling student with a turbulent home life, factors that defense attorneys would later argue made her vulnerable to manipulation.
The Shooting of Mary Jo Buttafuoco
On May 19, 1992, Fisher went to the Buttafuoco home in Massapequa, New York, and shot Mary Jo Buttafuoco in the head with a .25-caliber handgun. Miraculously, Mary Jo survived, though she suffered lasting facial paralysis and hearing loss. Fisher was arrested shortly afterward, and the case immediately drew intense media scrutiny.
Prosecutors initially charged Fisher with attempted murder, while her defense argued that she had been coerced and emotionally manipulated. The case quickly became less about legal nuance and more about spectacle, with tabloids assigning lurid nicknames and television crews camping outside courtrooms.
(Photo by Joe Kohen/Getty Images)
Criminal Case and Sentencing
Prosecutors initially charged Fisher with attempted murder, while her defense argued that she had been emotionally manipulated and pressured by Joey Buttafuoco. Facing the possibility of a lengthy prison sentence, Fisher ultimately accepted a plea agreement in December 1992.
She pleaded guilty to first-degree assault and was sentenced to five to fifteen years in prison. Fisher served approximately seven years before being released on parole in 1999.
Joey Buttafuoco, who denied encouraging the shooting, was later convicted of statutory rape related to his relationship with Fisher and served a brief jail sentence. The disparity in consequences became a lasting point of public controversy.
The Fisher case became a defining example of early 1990s tabloid culture. In 1993, three made-for-TV movies aired within weeks of one another, each dramatizing the story from a different perspective. The films were major ratings successes and helped cement the case as pop culture shorthand for scandal.
Fisher’s name became fodder for talk shows, comedians, and magazine covers, blurring the line between criminal justice and entertainment. The coverage also raised questions about how the media treats young defendants, especially young women, during high-profile cases.
Life After Prison
After her release, Fisher struggled to build a private life away from public scrutiny. She gave interviews, posed for magazines, and co-authored memoirs that framed her actions within the context of manipulation and immaturity. She also participated in reality television and celebrity boxing events, often leaning into the notoriety that followed her.
These appearances provided income but also reinforced her association with the crime, making reinvention difficult.
Adult Entertainment and Later Work
In the mid-2000s, Fisher again made headlines when she entered the adult entertainment industry. She stated that the decision was primarily financial and pragmatic, though it sparked renewed controversy and media attention.
In later years, she stepped back from public view, focusing on raising her children and pursuing private business interests. She has occasionally returned to the media to reflect on the case, often expressing regret and a desire to be seen as more than the crime that defined her youth.
Legacy and Public Perception
Amy Fisher remains a lasting symbol of how media sensationalism can amplify a criminal case into a cultural phenomenon. Her story continues to be referenced in discussions about statutory relationships, power imbalance, and the long-term consequences of teenage actions played out on a national stage.
More than three decades later, the case still resonates as a cautionary tale about fame born from scandal and the difficulty of escaping a narrative once it has taken hold.
All net worths are calculated using data drawn from public sources. When provided, we also incorporate private tips and feedback received from the celebrities or their representatives. While we work diligently to ensure that our numbers are as accurate as possible, unless otherwise indicated they are only estimates. We welcome all corrections and feedback using the button below.
