Democrats Now Openly Saying the Shutdown Is Theirs – HotAir
Up next
Author
Tags

Government shutdowns are always and everywhere about using government spending —or, really, the restriction of government spending —as political leverage. Sometimes they are used effectively, and sometimes not, but the goal is to impose pain on your negotiating partner and break their will. 





Since politicians are careful to avoid feeling any of the pain directly—they consider themselves essential employees and keep the money flowing into their own pockets—the pain has to be inflicted on others, with the hope that the victims can implore their legislators to give in to demands. 

Think of the whipping boy in monarchies. Since nobody can punish the royals, punishment is dealt out to a young boy in the hope that his entreaties will persuade the young prince or king to behave. 





Of course, no politician wants to tell their constituents that they are playing political games that result in harm to their voters, so they come up with what they hope to be persuasive arguments for shutting down the government (or at least parts of it). Sometimes the arguments are persuasive enough, but often not. Eventually, somebody gives in because they are getting the blame for the pain caused to voters. 

The Democrats’ arguments have fallen flat with the American public—fewer and fewer people think they have a point, and it is killing them in the polls. That is why, as I argued yesterday, the dike is crumbling and will soon come down. More Democrats are going to defect. 

Which is why the ones who want to keep going are admitting the fact that this is not about health care, or anything else. It is about exercising the only power they have. 





The most liberal members are the ones resorting to telling their voters a version of the truth: it’s leverage to get what Democrats want exactly as they want it. If this were about health care subsidies, both the president and the Republicans have said they want to come to a negotiated compromise. It’s not good policy to do so—eliminating Obamacare and replacing it with something sustainable is necessary—but few Republicans want to go into 2026 with some people getting massive hits to their wallets. 

So what they are really fighting for is funding for purely Democratic constituencies, such as illegal aliens and others whom they threw subsidies to under temporary COVID “emergency measures.” Democrats wouldn’t vote for these subsidies to be permanent when they controlled the House, the Senate, and the White House, but are going to the mat for them now as much to break Republican unity as to service their own constituencies. 





Democrats have been voting against bills to pay federal workers and the military, proving that they want the pain to go on because pain is their power. 

But the pain hits their own constituents most, which is why some Democrats are making their last pitch to their voters: if you want us to have power, you must endure the pain. They think this is Churchillian rallying of the troops, but it is hitting the ocean like a kamikaze plane shot down before it reaches the target. 

Federal workers are done with being the whipping boys, so they aren’t the target market for this messaging, and this is why it is the most progressive legislators who are talking about “leverage” and not their actual demands. The market is the extreme left, who want a fight and don’t care what it costs. 





The Democrats who care about winning elections in tough races want this over and done with, but they are all held hostage to the radical left, who want blood, even if much of it is their own. 

The media, which is more aligned with the Democratic establishment than the far left (outside MSNBC), has clearly gotten the signal: Help us end the shutdown. They are no longer running cover for the Democratic messaging, and at least some of that has to do with the desire of the establishment Democrats to defang the far left because they are hurting electoral chances. 

The civil war inside the Democratic Party has been simmering since the Obama years, and the first skirmish was the Hillary Clinton/Bernie Sanders race in 2016. The establishment won then, and again in 2020 with their pick of Joe Biden, who was similarly unpopular with the left. Ironically, Biden was, as president, the most far-left president ever, as the left took over his administration. And the left now dominates the party. 





The establishment wants its power back. Electorally, I doubt they can get it, but tactically, I suspect that they will win the shutdown battle because the left so obviously miscalculated. 

The thing about civil wars is that everybody loses. Every casualty is “on the same side” in at least one sense. In this case, no matter which Democratic faction “wins,” Democrats as a whole were the only casualties. 

The “leverage” argument may convince progressives to stick it out, but to most ordinary Americans, the message they hear is that Democrats are willing to sacrifice them in order to get as much power as possible. 

That’s not a compelling political message.



Editor’s Note: The Schumer Shutdown is here. Rather than put the American people first, Chuck Schumer and the radical Democrats forced a government shutdown for healthcare for illegals. They own this.

Help us continue to report the truth about the Schumer Shutdown. Use promo code POTUS47 to get 74% off your VIP membership.



You May Also Like
Carrie Underwood compared a young American Idol contestant to the iconic Taylor Swift on Sunday's new episode of the ABC reality competition series

Fans react after Carrie Underwood declares American Idol has found the ‘next Taylor Swift’

Carrie Underwood compared a young American Idol contestant to the iconic Taylor…
House Of Guinness star Anthony Boyle (centre-right) is reportedly the most recent actor to join the race to become the next James Bond

House Of Guinness star joins the James Bond race as ‘bookies name him as contender for 007 role’

House Of Guinness star Anthony Boyle is reportedly the most recent actor…
Kate Hudson, Gabrielle Union, more

Kate Hudson, Gabrielle Union, more

Stars like Julia Fox, Mandy Moore, and Keke Palmer attended the Fashion…
Alicia, 25, a personal trainer, is not interested in men who play video games or go clubbing every weekend. She also hoped her date would be taller than her 5ft 10in

‘I had a better conversation with a woman in the loo’: It wasn’t a match for Alicia and Dinesh

ALICIA, 25 Single for a year and a half. Dating Past? I’ve…