Most offices have that one person who somehow has everything you could possibly need. A bandage for a paper cut, a mint after lunch, an energy drink when the shift drags on—they always come through. Most coworkers appreciate that kind of thoughtfulness, and it usually helps build friendly connections at work. But sometimes, even good intentions can spiral into unexpected trouble.
That’s exactly what happened in this case, where a 21-year-old security guard offered a coworker feminine hygiene products during a night shift. Instead of a simple thank-you, the situation took a sharp turn when the woman filed a complaint with HR and even labeled him as “creepy” to others. What started as an act of kindness quickly became a workplace controversy. Keep reading, because the internet is split on who was really in the wrong here.
Working in security can come with unexpected responsibilities, especially when you’re interacting with people from all walks of life throughout long shifts
Image credits: freepik (not the actual image)
A 21-year-old shared how carrying feminine hygiene products to help coworkers unexpectedly landed him in trouble
Image credits: Towfiqu Barbhuiya (not the actual image)
Image credits: mazharrajpoot (not the actual image)
Image credits: Upstairs-General-681
Many employees avoid reporting senior staff because they fear being transferred, sidelined, or treated unfairly for speaking up
When work starts feeling heavy, it doesn’t usually happen all at once. One day the job feels fine, and the next, even opening your laptop feels exhausting. A promotion keeps getting “revisited.” A manager changes expectations every other week. Or there’s that one coworker who somehow makes every shift feel longer. Little annoyances can stack up quietly. Before you know it, the job that felt manageable starts feeling like a constant weight.
In theory, many work issues can be solved by simply talking things out. A direct conversation can sometimes clear misunderstandings. If that doesn’t work, there’s always HR—or at least, that’s how it’s supposed to be. In reality, many employees hesitate to go that route. One major reason is fear of not being taken seriously. A 2019 HR Acuity Employee Experience Survey found that over 56% of workers had witnessed or experienced inappropriate or unethical behavior. Yet many incidents went unreported. Fear of consequences often keeps people silent.
Another big concern is retaliation, especially when the complaint involves someone senior. Employees worry they might be transferred to another department or location. Others fear being pushed out of key projects. Reporting a manager can feel especially risky. Power dynamics make people nervous. That uncertainty alone is enough to stop many from speaking up. For some, staying quiet feels safer than rocking the boat.
Then there’s the fear of social fallout at work. Being labeled as “the complainer” can be isolating. Coworkers may start acting distant or uncomfortable. It can feel a lot like school, where reporting a problem makes you stand out. Office dynamics can shift fast. People may stop sharing information. Lunch tables suddenly feel smaller. That sense of alienation can be just as stressful as the original issue.
Career growth is another major worry. Employees often fear being seen as “difficult” or “not a team player.” They worry complaints might quietly affect performance reviews. Raises and promotions may suddenly feel out of reach. Even if no one says it out loud, the concern lingers. People don’t want to be remembered for conflict. They want to be remembered for results. That fear keeps many people stuck in silence.
Some employees also worry about the impact on their coworkers. What if reporting leads to layoffs or disciplinary action that affects the whole team? What if it makes work harder for everyone else? Guilt plays a role here. People don’t want to feel responsible for creating tension. They may choose to endure discomfort rather than risk harming others. Protecting peers can sometimes outweigh protecting oneself. It’s an emotional burden many carry quietly.
At the same time, there are people who run to HR over minor inconveniences, which can water down serious complaints and make genuine issues harder to address
On the flip side, HR professionals point out another reality. Jill Santopietro Panall, owner of 21Oak HR Consulting in Boston, explains that some employees assume the other person will automatically face consequences. That’s not always the case. Investigations look at all sides. Sometimes responsibility isn’t one-sided. Complaints can reveal shared fault. This possibility makes some employees hesitate. They fear the spotlight might turn back on them.
And while there are many people who hesitate to go to HR even when they have a genuine reason, there’s also another side to it. Some people run to HR over absolutely minor issues. You know the type—the ones who complain because their chair was moved or because someone looked at them the wrong way. Situations like this can make real concerns harder to take seriously.
In this particular case, it seemed like the security guard was genuinely trying to be helpful. On the other hand, some commenters pointed out that topics like this can feel very personal, and not everyone is comfortable with that kind of help. What are your thoughts on this situation? Let us know.
Many people online pointed out that the woman may have been looking for an excuse to leave work early and shifted the blame onto him
Others felt that, while well-intentioned, it wasn’t his place to get involved in such a sensitive and personal matter
