Medical shows, by their very nature, are emotional stories. Even the comedic series emphasize the fact that the high-stakes world of medicine often comes with heartbreaking patient cases. Over time, many medical shows have become known for telling stories about people experiencing some of the worst moments of their lives, and the people who care for them. Medical shows often follow a balance of heartbreak and hope.
Medical series can be so emotional because they tap into some of the most universal human experiences. Some series introduce characters who use humor to cope with the difficult and sometimes horrifying situations they regularly face. Other series highlight the fact that anyone working in healthcare inevitably has to provide patient care while dealing with their own heartbreaking circumstances. The most emotional medical series of all time allow viewers to feel each emotion deeply.
10
‘Scrubs’ (2001–2010)
Scrubs is an American medical comedy that follows the staff of the fictional Sacred Heart Hospital. Specifically, the series is told from the perspective of Dr. “J.D.” Dorian (Zach Braff), who begins the series as an intern. Scrubs follows J.D.’s perspective as he sometimes gets lost in his own fantasies to process his job. J.D. rises through the ranks of the hospital and eventually leaves Sacred Heart to become a Residency Director.
Although Scrubs is technically a medical comedy series, that distinction never stopped the show from telling some truly devastating stories. Although the characters all used their signature brand of humor to cope with the day-to-day stresses of their job, they all had to face the sometimes heartbreaking realities of seeing people on their worst days. Scrubs hurts so good because these characters use their sense of humor to connect with their patients and each other.
9
‘The Good Doctor’ (2017–2024)
The Good Doctor introduces Dr. Shaun Murphy (Freddie Highmore), a young surgeon with autism who relocates to San Jose, California, to work at St. Bonaventure Hospital. The series follows Shaun’s growth as a surgeon, and the fact that he has to work harder than many of his colleagues to be taken seriously because of his age. The Good Doctor‘s episodes focus on Shaun’s ability to appreciate details that others miss, even if he sometimes struggles to connect with patients and others emotionally.
Shaun had to fight for everything he achieved as a doctor, especially since he achieved so much so young. This often led to particularly heartbreaking situations where he had to be at his most vulnerable to prove himself to others. A major theme of the show was Shaun facing grief, rejection, acceptance, love, and trauma. Shaun and the rest of the St. Bonaventure team also had to face many patients facing catastrophic diagnoses and medical emergencies that pushed them to their emotional limits.
8
‘New Amsterdam’ (2018–2023)
New Amsterdam is based on the non-fiction book Twelve Patients: Life and Death at Bellevue Hospital by Eric Manheimer. The series follows Dr. Max Goodwin (Ryan Eggold), the newly appointed medical director of New Amsterdam Hospital in New York City. New Amsterdam chronicles Max’s quest to improve healthcare for all patients and the fact that he and his staff consistently have to reckon with how broken America’s healthcare system is.
In the beginning, much of the heartbreak in New Amsterdam revolved around the fact that Max had to face the reality that he himself needed care himself while being a doctor. As the series continued, New Amsterdam established itself as one of the most heartbreaking medical dramas because it examined the system inequities that continue to exist in the American healthcare system. Watching New Amsterdam is such an emotional experience because it presents characters who exist between idealism and reality.
7
‘The Resident’ (2018–2023)
The Resident follows staff members at Chastain Park Memorial Hospital in Atlanta, Georgia. The series starts by introducing the titular resident physician, Dr. Conrad Hawkins (Matt Czuchry). The Resident mainly focuses on the complex healthcare industry in America and how the for-profit system impacts patients. The series explores the reality of what healthcare looks like in a for-profit system, where there are always those ready to take advantage of the system.
The Resident is another example of a series that explored the heartbreak that came from the chronic neglect of an overburdened healthcare system. What makes the series even more emotional is the fact that it presents stories of people who will try to profit from patients and their misfortunes. Toward the end, one of the most heartbreaking moments of the series came from the tragic death of Nic Nevin (Emily VanCamp), one of the series’ most beloved characters.
6
‘House’ (2004–2012)
House introduces the titular character, Dr. Gregory House (Hugh Laurie), a diagnostician who struggles with his own demons while doing his best to diagnose patients with complex medical conditions. What House lacks in bedside manner, he makes up for in sheer force of will in his determination to get to the bottom of each case. Throughout the series, House frequently breaks norms, protocols, and existing rules to make final diagnoses before time runs out.
Although House was more of a medical detective drama, the protagonist himself had plenty of emotional moments. Many of House‘s most emotional beats came from the fact that he often had his own way of showing care and compassion to his patients despite his gruff exterior. It was always heartbreaking to watch him try to process his own physical and emotional pain while doing his best to show up for his patients in his own way.
5
‘The Pitt’ (2025–)
The Pitt follows the emergency medical staff at the fictional Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center as they do their best to save as many lives as possible while being chronically underfunded and under-resourced. Specifically, the series follows Dr. Robby (Noah Wyle), an attending physician who has to process his own trauma after the death of his mentor. Each episode chronicles a single hour in one of the worst shifts of these characters’ lives.
Even in its first season, The Pitt has distinguished itself as one of the most heartbreaking medical dramas of all time. What makes The Pitt such an emotional medical drama is the fact that it’s an honest look at what healthcare workers face in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic. The series stands out for its emotional honesty because it highlights the daily struggle real emergency workers face as they do their best with little to no support.
4
‘ER’ (1994–2009)
ER is a landmark medical series that follows the emergency medical staff of the fictional Cook County General Hospital. The show is another example of one that highlights the many challenges these healthcare specialists face as they balance saving lives with the fact that they often treat patients who have fallen through the cracks in the system. The series features a revolving cast of characters who each face their own personal challenges while saving lives on a daily basis.
ER featured deeply emotional patient stories throughout its run, and showed how cumulative losses, including unpredictable and tragic deaths, impacted the hospital staff. These characters faced personal traumas just as complex as the medical ones, which often had devastating emotional consequences. Additionally, ER succeeded in highlighting how emotionally taxing emergency medicine is for patients and staff alike.
3
‘Private Practice’ (2007–2013)
Private Practice is a spin-off of Grey’s Anatomy, and follows Dr. Addison Montgomery (Kate Walsh) as she leaves Seattle Grace Hospital to join a private wellness clinic in Los Angeles called the Oceanside Wellness Group. The series explores the personal and professional lives of Addison and her new colleagues as they navigate complex medical cases. Private Practice explores the ethics of medicine as the staff of Oceanside treat patients, often facing extraordinary circumstances.
Private Practice is one of the most emotional medical dramas ever because it dives deeper into personal pain, moral complexity, and emotional vulnerability that healthcare workers and patients face. The series presented stories involving difficult subjects, like infertility, miscarriage, sexual assault, mental illness, child abuse, end-of-life care, and abortion, with emotional nuance. Private Practice is ultimately such an emotional series because it allows viewers to sit in discomfort and sadness.
2
‘Grey’s Anatomy’ (2005–)
Grey’s Anatomy is the longest-running medical drama of all time. The series mainly follows Dr. Meredith Grey (Ellen Pompeo), who is first introduced as a surgical intern before she moves through the ranks of Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. Grey’s Anatomy is less a medical drama and is more of an exploration of the complexity of human relationships. The series is known for its dramatic twists, intense romances, and its often heartbreaking stories.
Grey’s Anatomy is considered one of the most emotional medical dramas of all time because it doesn’t just focus on saving lives. Instead, it focuses on how patients’ lives and the lives of those saving them are profoundly impacted by the chaos of the hospital. The series combines these intense medical emergencies with heartbreaking personal losses. Ultimately, Grey’s Anatomy makes viewers feel every emotion and reminds everyone what being human really means.
1
‘M*A*S*H’ (1972–1983)
M*A*S*H is a unique medical series that combines drama and comedy as it follows the staff of an American Mobile Army Surgical Hospital during the Korean War. The series follows Dr. Benjamin Franklin “Hawkeye” Pierce (Alan Alda), a surgeon and civilian draftee. M*A*S*H highlights the emotional toll war takes on anyone living through it. The series also explores the horrors of combat, the absurdity of military bureaucracy, and the struggle to maintain humanity in such an inhumane environment.
M*A*S*H is the most emotionally devastating medical series ever because of its raw depiction of suffering, loss, and resilience in an environment where death was a daily reality. The characters often masked their grief and stress with humor, but the emotional weight is always just beneath the surface. Rather than simply showcasing the horrors of war without context, M*A*S*H examines what it means to survive these events.
