Parents turn to breast pumps for a variety of reasons. Perhaps they’re in a position where baby can’t feed and are exclusively expressing, or maybe the choice is to combine breast milk with formula feeds, or the need for a breast pump may be down to a lifestyle change, when returning to work, for example. Regardless of the situation, the best breast pumps can be a mum’s best friend.
Anxiety over the pressure of ensuring baby is well fed is something many new parents face, all while battling with the sleepless nights, erratic hormones and potential engorged, sore and swollen breasts. So, it’s important to consider your choices when it comes to choosing the best breast pump for you, as you’ll want something that’s not only comfortable to wear but efficient and compatible with your lifestyle.
The breast pump market can be a minefield. You may be trying to decide between a manual or an electric pump; wondering if it’s better to opt for a single or double model; and pondering whether a hands-free version that sits in your bra can really work (the answer is yes, and we’re here for it).
To help you make that all-important decision when it comes to your pump purchase, I’ve tried and tested a range of electric, hands-free wearable pumps and manual options.
How I tested
I put each pump through its paces at different stages of breastfeeding to get a real feel for how each pump performed, expressing at varying times of the day and night.
In particular, I made notes on the following key factors:
- Efficiency: A key factor to consider when selecting the best breast pumps was how efficient they were, including suction and speed. I assessed each one’s efficiency during a 20-minute pumping session and measured how much breast milk was pumped.
- Suction power: I looked for pumps that could effectively mimic a baby’s natural nursing rhythm and were strong enough to express milk efficiently, but gentle enough to avoid discomfort. Suction strength can make a big difference in both how much milk you’re able to express and how quickly the session goes, so I tested each pump at various settings to see how well they balanced performance and comfort.
- Maintenance: I paid close attention to how easy each pump was to clean, how many parts needed washing, and whether any components were dishwasher-safe. I also looked at how intuitive the assembly and disassembly processes were, especially for tired parents doing it multiple times a day.
- Ease of use: I looked at how simple it was to set up right out of the box, how clear the controls were, and whether adjusting settings felt intuitive or confusing. I also considered how easy it was to position the pump correctly and whether the design made the experience feel more or less stressful. Bonus points were given to those you could wear in a bra.
- Noise level: I know how important discretion and comfort can be, especially when pumping at work, during the night, or around a sleeping baby. I tested each pump in different settings to see how noticeable the sound was and whether it could be heard through a closed door or over a phone call. Some pumps were surprisingly quiet, while others had a distinct hum or mechanical noise that could feel disruptive.
- Compatibility with bottles and accessories: I looked at whether each pump worked with a variety of bottle brands or required special parts, and whether adaptors were included or easy to find. I also tested how well the pumps integrated with storage bags, bottle warmers, and sterilisers.
- Cost: I wanted to make sure each pump offered good value for money, no matter the budget. I looked at what was included in the price (like spare parts, bottles, or a carrying case) and whether a higher price actually translated to better performance, comfort, or convenience.
The best breast pumps for 2025 are:
- Best overall – Lola&Lykke smart electric breast pump: £105, Naturalbabyshower.co.uk
- Best budget buy – Medela harmony flex manual breast pump: £25, Medela.co.uk
- Best wearable option – Medela freestyle hands-free double electric wearable breast pump: £299.99, Johnlewis.com
- Best for battery life – Vital Baby nurture flexcone electric breast pump: £61.71, Amazon.co.uk
- Best for quiet pumping – Elvie stride single: £126.75, Pramworld.co.uk
